Delight Your Taste Buds with This Delectable Pizza Recipe

If pizza is your go-to comfort food, then you are in for a treat. As a culinary explorer, I have discovered the perfect copycat recipe of Mellow Mushroom’s “Magical Mystery Tour” pizza. This pizza is a classic, ranking high on the list of Mellow Mushroom’s specialty pizzas. It’s called “magical” for a reason – it truly is magical in every sense of the word.

Mellow Mushroom is a well-known restaurant chain that serves some of the best pizzas. The “Magical Mystery Tour” pizza has been on their menu for quite some time now and has been a fan favorite since its release. This pizza is made with baby portabella mushrooms, mozzarella cheese, feta cheese, pesto sauce, and topped off with Mellow Mushroom’s own Mellow Red Sauce – this secret ingredient takes the pizza to the next level.

If you’re wondering what makes this dish so special, it’s the combination of flavors that will take you on a delicious journey. The baby portabella mushrooms add an earthy flavor to this pizza while the pesto sauce provides that perfect burst of herbaceousness . Meanwhile, feta cheese adds tanginess that complements the creaminess of mozzarella cheese, making it a match made in heaven.

In this article, I will walk you through all the necessary steps to make your own “Magical Mystery Tour” pizza at home. Not only will you save money by making this dish at home but you’ll impress your friends and family with your cooking skills too! So, let’s get started on this adventure to make a pizza pie like no other.

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

Mellow Mushroom
Mellow Mushroom “magical Mystery Tour” Pizza (Copycat)

Are you ready for a pizza experience that will take your taste buds on a Magical Mystery Tour? Look no further than the Mellow Mushroom “Magical Mystery Tour” Pizza! This copycat recipe of Mellow Mushroom’s beloved specialty pizza is sure to be a hit with pizza lovers everywhere.

What sets this pizza apart from the rest? For one, it features a unique combination of baby portabella mushrooms and mozzarella cheese, complemented by tangy feta cheese and bright pesto sauce. All of these delicious ingredients are piled high on top of a fluffy focaccia bread crust that is made classic-style and tossed with garlic butter and parmesan for extra flavor.

But what really makes this pizza magical is Mellow Mushroom’s secret ingredient – an irresistible red sauce infused with a blend of herbs and spices. It’s like no other sauce you’ve tasted before and truly elevates the entire pizza-eating experience.

The best part? This pizza is versatile enough to satisfy any craving, whether you’re in the mood for a vegetarian option or want to add your favorite toppings. Plus, it’s easy to make at home so you can enjoy your own slice of pizza heaven anytime you want.

Trust me, as someone who has indulged in more than my fair share of this pizza, I can guarantee that the Mellow Mushroom “Magical Mystery Tour” Pizza will become your new hands-down favorite in no time. So gear up, sit back and let your taste buds take you on an unforgettable journey!

Ingredient List

Before diving in, let’s take a look at the ingredients you will need for this copycat recipe of Mellow Mushroom’s Magical Mystery Tour Pizza. Don’t worry; you won’t need any exotic or hard-to-find ingredients. All of the components can be found easily in your local grocery stores or supermarkets.

  • Pizza crust: You can make your own pizza crust using a classic dough recipe or buy one from the store.
  • Red sauce: Mellow Mushroom uses their magical red sauce as the base for their pizzas. You can recreate this by mixing tomato paste, garlic, and Italian seasonings.
  • Cheeses: This pizza mainly features mozzarella and feta cheese that play perfectly off each other with their distinct flavors.
  • Pesto sauce: The secret ingredient that elevates this pizza from good to great is pesto sauce. It gives a bold flavor that will leave everyone wanting more.
  • Baby portobello mushrooms: These mushrooms have a meaty texture and robust flavor perfect for savory dishes like pizzas.
  • Garlic butter parmesan: We’ll use this mixture to brush on the crust before and after baking to add flavor and aroma that will tickle your senses.
  • Pizza Toppings: The Magical Mystery Tour pizza also includes spinach, onions, tomatoes, and a sprinkle of Kosmic Karma seasoning.

Note: The quantity of ingredients mentioned above is for making one 14-inch pizza pie required to serve one-kind pizza. If you plan to serve more people, adjust the quantity accordingly.

The Recipe How-To

Let’s Get Started: Making the Mellow Mushroom “Magical Mystery Tour” Pizza at Home!

Who doesn’t love a good homemade pizza? Especially one that is as tasty as the original. To start off, you will need to preheat your oven to 450°F. While waiting, gather all the necessary ingredients and kitchen tools. Are you ready for this step-by-step process of making magic in the kitchen?

Preparing the Pizza Crust

To make the crust, use a classic dough recipe or simply purchase a pre-made focaccia bread from your local grocery store. Toss the dough, flatten it out onto a baking sheet, and sprinkle with cornmeal.

The Delicious Secret Sauce

The delicious sauce used in this pizza is what makes it so special! It’s creamy, garlicky, and packed with herbs. It’s made with pesto sauce mixed with Mellow Red Sauce, which is Mellow Mushroom’s secret ingredient that gives the pizza its unique flavor.

The Topping Combinations

For toppings, slice up some baby portobello mushrooms and button mushrooms and set them aside. Grate some mozzarella cheese & feta cheese using a coarse grater. To get that lovely garlicky aroma into every bite of your pizza, brush the crust with a mixture of tossed garlic butter and parmesan cheese.

Assembling Your Pizza Pie

Spread sauce over crust leaving an inch or so border for crust. Sprinkle mozzarella cheese over sauce then dot feta cheese around pie. Add sliced mushrooms on top of cheese.

Cooking Time!

Once assembled slide pizza into oven immediately onto preheated pizza stone or pan. Short cook time allows for crisp crust while keeping toppings fresh hot and bubbly.

Enjoying Your Creation!

Once cooked, remove from oven, let it cool down just enough to be able to slice it up into 6 equal parts because let’s face it – sharing is caring! This pizza serves one kind pizza pie that’s perfect as dinner on its own or as part of a fun night in with friends watching movies and drinking a cold beer or two.

We hope you enjoy creating your very own Mellow Mushroom “Magical Mystery Tour” copycat pizza recipe at home as much as we did!

Substitutions and Variations

While the Mellow Mushroom “Magical Mystery Tour” pizza is a hands-down favorite, there are many ways to create a unique pizza of your own. The beauty of pizza lies in its versatility, allowing you to customize it to your heart’s content with different toppings and crusts. Here are some substitutions and variations that can help create your perfect pie.

For the mushroom lovers, baby portabella or button portobello mushrooms make excellent substitutes for the mushroom blend. You can choose the kind of cheese you want to use too! Mozzarella cheese tends to be the go-to choice for pizza, but for some variety, try using feta cheese or other soft cheeses like ricotta or goat cheese.

If you’re looking for an alternative to the pesto sauce or red sauce used in this recipe, you can experiment with different sauces like alfredo or barbecue sauce. Alternatively, you can skip the sauce altogether and opt for olive oil, garlic butter or even hummus as a base.

For those counting calories or seeking lighter options, thin crust or homemade pizza crust recipes work great. A gluten-free or cauliflower crust can also be delicious. You can choose to add different toppings based on dietary needs; for instance, vegetarian pizzas can be created easily by skipping meat toppings entirely and increasing veggie options such as bell peppers and onions.

Beer is a perfect pairing with pizza, so next time consider enjoying your pie with an ice-cold beer on the side.

Don’t hesitate to get creative and experiment with different combinations until you find your perfect pizza!

Serving and Pairing

Mellow Mushroom’s Magical Mystery Tour pizza is a deliciously filling dish that can be enjoyed as a meal on its own or paired with your favorite sides. The crust of the pizza is made in-house and is both crispy and chewy, providing a perfect base for the flavorful toppings.

When it comes to serving this pizza, I personally like to cut it into eight equal slices, which allows everyone to enjoy a generous portion. The bold flavors of the baby portabella mushrooms, mozzarella cheese, feta cheese, and pesto sauce blend together beautifully on each slice without overpowering one another.

As for pairing options, the Magical Mystery Tour pizza goes well with a variety of sides and beverages. A side of Mellow Mushroom’s signature butter parmesan served along with the pizza is always a great idea. You may also pair this pizza with a fresh garden salad to balance out its richness. It pairs perfectly with red wines like Pinot Noir or Chianti, or refreshing beer.

If you’re looking to make it more of a meal experience, consider adding one of Mellow Mushroom’s famous starters like their Kosmic Karma or garlic breadsticks to complement the flavors of the pizza. With all these options as back-up for the main course, you’ll have an enjoyable dining experience of flavors complementing each other.

Overall, this tantalizing pizza serves one kind of pizza pie that will definitely impress your guests when served in social gatherings. It could become your hands favorite pizza after giving it a try it anytime soon.

Make-Ahead, Storing and Reheating

This Mellow Mushroom “Magical Mystery Tour” Pizza Copycat Recipe is perfect for a casual meal with family or friends. To make things easier and more convenient for you, there is an option to make this pizza ahead of time so that you don’t have to spend time cooking on the day of your event.

You can make the pizza crust up to 3 days in advance and store it in an airtight container in the refrigerator. You can also prepare the pesto sauce ahead of time and freeze it in small batches, so it’s ready whenever you need it. Remember to thaw the sauce overnight in the refrigerator before using it.

If you want to prepare the entire pizza ahead of time, bake it as directed, let it cool completely, then wrap it tightly in plastic wrap and store it in the refrigerator for up to three days. When you are ready to reheat, preheat your oven to 375°F, place the unwrapped pizza on a baking sheet, and bake for 10-15 minutes until heated through.

Alternatively, you can freeze unbaked pizzas for up to two months. Wrap each pizza tightly in plastic wrap before freezing. When ready to eat, unwrap and allow the pizza to come to room temperature for about 30 minutes before baking as directed.

This recipe calls for a thin crust pizza that can be made using simple ingredients found at any local grocery store. Whether you are entertaining guests or looking for a homemade pizza night, making sure that your crust is prepared perfectly will ensure that your meal tastes amazing every time.

Overall, this recipe is versatile and easy-to-make even on busy weeknights. So make it ahead or freeze for later when you are short on time but still want some mouth-watering “Mellow Mushroom Magical Mystery Tour” pizza enjoyed by all!

Tips for Perfect Results

If you want to create the perfect Mellow Mushroom “Magical Mystery Tour” Pizza, there are a few tips that you should keep in mind. As someone who has tried and tested this recipe multiple times, I’d love to share some tricks to make sure you get the best result possible.

First and foremost, choosing the right ingredients is critical to getting a flavorful pizza. Use fresh baby portobello mushrooms and quality mozzarella and feta cheese. Opt for homemade pesto sauce, or alternatively, use store-bought versions that do not contain added sugar.

When it comes to the crust of pizza, making it from scratch is always an ideal option. Therefore, take the time to make classic dough and ensure it is adequately proofed. Toss the dough using garlic butter parmesan mixture, and spread it evenly over the pan or baking stone.

Another essential tip is making sure that your oven is preheated thoroughly before baking. It should be set at 450 degrees Fahrenheit (230C°) because it’s necessary to cook high heat for thin-crust pizza.

During baking, keep an eye on your pizza until it becomes crispy golden brown to know if it’s ready to be taken out of the oven. Once done, remove from the oven, slice with a sharp knife or pizza cutter into eight pieces.

Lastly, don’t hesitate to try out different variations! You can use seasoned pressed tofu instead of cheese if you’re looking for a vegan option. Alternatively, add other toppings such as prosciutto or chicken if you’re looking for more protein.

With these tips, you can now perfect your Mellow Mushroom “Magical Mystery Tour” pizza recipe and enjoy some delicious homemade pizza every time.


As with any recipe, preparation and execution come with some uncertainty. That is why I have put together a list of frequently asked questions that should help you troubleshoot any issues that may arise while making your very own Mellow Mushroom “Magical Mystery Tour” pizza (copycat) at home. These questions range from common substitutes to ingredient quantity inquiries and more. Please read on for answers to these inquiries to ensure that your pizza-making experience is nothing but smooth sailing.

What is on the Magical Mystery Tour pizza Mellow Mushroom?

Get ready to take a flavorful journey with a pizza that will transport your taste buds to another dimension. A pesto base pizza with a crispy crust, topped with button and Portobello mushrooms, Mozzarella cheese, fresh spinach, tangy Feta, and a spicy kick of Jalapenos. And what better way to elevate the experience than pairing it with a cold beer straight from the tap! So let’s get cooking and embark on this magical mystery tour of taste.

What is the secret ingredient in mellow mushroom?

I’ve got a pizza recipe that even those who despise crust will devour. Inspired by a Mellow Mushroom creation, the key to this crust’s deliciousness is a secret ingredient- molasses!

What kind of pizza crust does Mellow Mushroom use?

At Mellow, we are passionate about crafting the perfect dough for our pizzas, calzones, and pretzels. To achieve this, we are meticulous in our selection of ingredients; we only settle for the finest high protein, unbromated unbleached wheat flour, pure Appalachian spring water and avoid refined white sugar. Our commitment to using top-quality ingredients is evident in the superior taste and texture of our dough.

Does Mellow Mushroom pizza crust have eggs?

Mellow Mushroom’s dough could contain eggs and dairy, hence, vegetarians can indulge in their pizza, but vegans might need to opt for a different alternative.

Bottom Line

In conclusion, the Mellow Mushroom “Magical Mystery Tour” Pizza is a pizza pie that truly lives up to its name – magical and mysterious in every bite. With the secret ingredient of pesto sauce and the perfect combination of baby portabella mushrooms, mozzarella cheese, feta cheese, and garlic butter parmesan, this copycat recipe will not disappoint.

If you are looking for a new kind of pizza experience, I highly recommend trying out this delectable pie. It is perfect for a night in with friends or as a special treat for yourself. Plus, with the option to customize and substitute toppings, you can make it your own and create endless variations.

As a culinary explorer and food enthusiast, I have savored my fair share of pizzas, but Mellow Mushroom’s “Magical Mystery Tour” Pizza is hands down my favorite. Whether you visit one of their restaurants or decide to make it at home with this recipe guide in hand, this pizza will not disappoint.

So go ahead and treat yourself to the best pizza experience out there. Your taste buds will thank you.

Mellow Mushroom

Mellow Mushroom “magical Mystery Tour” Pizza (Copycat) Recipe

This is hands down my favorite pizza on the planet. Mellow Mushroom is this awesome restaurant we have here on the east coast and this pizza will definatly blow your socks off!! Its amazing. For the Crust I used "The Easiest, Bestest Focaccia Bread Ever!!" recipe which is Recipe #27968. Trust me you will LOVE this pizza!!
No ratings yet
Prep Time 1 hr
Cook Time 30 mins
Course Main Course
Cuisine Pizza
Servings 1 pizza
Calories 99 kcal


  • focaccia bread, crust (The Easiest, Bestest Focaccia Bread Ever!!)
  • 1 (10 ounce) jar pesto sauce (I use classico brand)
  • 1/2 cup feta cheese (crumbled)
  • 1 cup mozzarella cheese (grated)
  • 8 ounces baby portabella mushrooms (sliced)
  • 1 1/2 cups Baby Spinach
  • 1 jalapeno (sliced) (optional)


  • Prepare the Focaccia recipe as instructed (Recipe #27968).
  • Slice the mushrooms.
  • Crumble the Feta.
  • Shred the Mozzarella Cheese.
  • Slice the Jalapeno.
  • Have the Spinach ready and cleaned.
  • After the dough is prepared, roll it out and place in on a pizza pan.
  • Spread the pesto (I use about half a small jar per pizza).
  • Top the pizza with mushrooms first then with the Spinach, Mozarelle, Jalapenos and then Feta.
  • Place in the oven at about 400'F for about 20-30 Minutes. and Enjoy.
  • **(optional--chop 2 cloves of garlic and mix with melted butter then brush on the crust of the pizza when it comes out of the oven and then sprinkle the crust with parmasan cheese).

Your Own Notes


Serving: 59gCalories: 99kcalCarbohydrates: 2.7gProtein: 6.9gFat: 7gSaturated Fat: 4.3gCholesterol: 25.9mgSodium: 265.9mgFiber: 0.7gSugar: 1.7g
Keyword < 4 Hours, Inexpensive
Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!

Recommended Recipes Just For You

None found